FAULTY ANALOGY

Section: Form

Explanation
Example
Definition of Faulty Analogy:
To reason analogically is to reason that because two or more things or types of things are alike in some one or more respects (we may call this the antecedent resemblance), they will therefore be found alike in some other respect(s) - the consequent resemblance. In cases of reliable analogies the antecedent factor is already known to have some bearing on the consequent factor. In faulty analogies such knowledge is lacking. The form of the argument is: B is like C in respect D; therefore B is like C in respect E.

'Last quarter I had a student by the name of Orzymski who did good work. This quarter I have another student by that name, and I'm expecting good work from him.'

See more Examples of Faulty Analogy: Playsm