DISPROVING A MINOR POINT

Section: Maneuver

Explanation
Example
Definition of Disproving a Minor Point:
When you have, say, two or more pieces of evidence of varying degree of importance, your opponent takes one of the less weighty of your arguments (perhaps a rather trivial point) and discredits that. He then acts as if (or attempts to create the impression that) he has disproved your whole case.

Jones: 'I believe that the instalment system of buying has been a boon to America, since, 1) it has enabled the ordinary man to have what has hitherto been only a luxury for the well-to-do; 2) it has raised the standard of living; 3) it has provided employment for many clerks, typists, etc., who must keep instalment accounts.' Smith: 'After all, the head of a gang of thieves provides gainful employment, and so any defence of instalment buying on the grounds of its providing employment is silly and evades the question as to whether this kind of employment is desirable. Therefore, I don't see that you have presented any substantial reason for favoring instalment buying.'

See more Examples of Disproving a Minor Point: Playsm